Reply to the 'Comment on "Topography of the Free Energy Landscape on the Claisen-Schmidt Condensation: Solvent and Temperature Effect in the Rate-Controlling Step"' by N. D. Coutinho, H. G. Machado, V. H. Carvalho-Silva and W. A. da Silva, , 2021, , 6738.

In the Comment on our paper on the description of the Gibbs Free energy profile of Claisen-Schmidt condensation, it is claimed that our calculations are flawed due to inconsistencies with experimental isotope effects in aqueous acetonitrile. In this Reply, we presented rigorous arguments, ambiguities in the Comment and new calculations confirming the consistency of our results: (i) small differences in the relative energetic barriers in both experimental and theoretical curves make the assignment of the rate-limiting step debatable, making the concept of RCS questionable; (ii) it is shown how the misinterpretation of the elementary steps and of the overall processes rate constants led the Comment to incorrect conclusions about the behavior of the inverse isotopic effect; (iii) neglect in the Comment of the inverse kinetic isotope effect in step R2 due to the hybridization conversion, and of the inverse equilibrium isotopic effect for step R1 to describe an overall iKIE > 1, (iv) an erroneous suggestion in the Comment that the disagreement between experimental kinetic parameters is due to the fact that acetonitrile is not used in previous experimental works, when contradictorily the literature recommends it as being indispensable to allow kinetic accuracy; and (v) new calculations improved by explicit-implicit hybrid treatment again ensure that step R4, and not step R5, can assume the role of RCS in protic solvents. Recognizing that questioning is an excellent path for promoting understanding, we hope that the answers provided here will help to clarify and expand the pertinent topics under discussion.

Topography of the free energy landscape of Claisen-Schmidt condensation: solvent and temperature effects on the rate-controlling step.

Recent studies have found that hydroxide elimination and the C[double bond, length as m-dash]C bond formation step in base-promoted aldol condensation have a strong influence on the overall rate of the reaction, in contrast to the well-accepted first enolization or C-C bond formation step. Here, applying theoretical models to the prototypical reaction of chalcone formation, the complete free energy profile of Claisen-Schmidt condensation is assessed, revealing how a protic solvent and a slight increase in temperature can induce the second enolization as the rate-controlling step (RCS). It is also observed: i) the nonexistence of a step with a much higher energetic barrier than the others, making the concept of RCS debatable; and ii) that the overall inverse kinetic isotopic effect does not exclude second enolization as a RCS in protic continuum medium.

Combined Role of the Asymmetric Counteranion-Directed Catalysis (ACDC) and Ionic Liquid Effect for the Enantioselective Biginelli Multicomponent Reaction.

This work describes new chiral task-specific ionic liquids bearing chiral anions as the catalysts for the enantioselective multicomponent Biginelli reaction. For the first time, the combined role of asymmetric counteranion-directed catalysis (ACDC) and ionic liquid effect (ILE) for the chiral induction in the Biginelli multicomponent reaction is demonstrated. The chiral induction arises from a supramolecular aggregate where the anion and the cation of the catalyst are alongside with a key cationic intermediate of the reaction.

From Live Cells to : Selective Staining and Quantification of Lipid Structures Using a Fluorescent Hybrid Benzothiadiazole Derivative.

The current article describes the synthesis, characterization, and application of a designed hybrid fluorescent BTD-coumarin (2,1,3-benzothiadiazole-coumarin) derivative (named ). The use of for live-cells staining showed excellent results, and lipid droplets (LDs) could be selectively stained. When compared with the commercially available dye (BODIPY) for LD staining, it was noted that the designed hybrid fluorescence was capable of staining a considerable larger number of LDs in both live and fixed cells (ca.

Heteropolyacid-Containing Ionic Liquid-Catalyzed Multicomponent Synthesis of Bridgehead Nitrogen Heterocycles: Mechanisms and Mitochondrial Staining.

The current manuscript describes the use of a heteropolyacid-containing task-specific ionic liquid, supported in imidazolium-based ionic liquids, as the catalyst for an efficient multicomponent synthesis of hexahydroimidazo[1,2-α]pyridine derivatives. The reactions conditions were fully optimized, and the bridgehead nitrogen heterocycle derivatives could be obtained in just 1 h exclusively as a single isomer ( trans). Single crystal X-ray analysis confirmed the trans derivative as the only isomer.

Charge-tagged N-heterocyclic carbenes (NHC): Direct transfer from ionic liquid solutions and long-lived nature in the gas phase.

Negatively charge-tagged N-heterocyclic carbenes have been formed in solution via deprotonation of imidazolium ions bearing acid side groups and transferred to the gas phase via ESI(-)-MS. The structure of the putative and apparently stable gaseous carbenes formed in such conditions were then probed via reactions with carbon dioxide using a triple quadrupole mass spectrometer particularly optimized for ion/molecule reactions of ESI-generated ions. Complete conversion to imidazolium carboxylates was achieved, which seems to demonstrate the efficiency of the transfer, the gas-phase stability, and the long-lived nature of these unprecedented charge-tagged carbenes and their predominance in the ionic population.

Fluorescent Peptoids as Selective Live Cell Imaging Probes.

This paper describes the synthesis of fluorescent peptoids using the Ugi multicomponent reaction (4CR). The four synthesized structures had their photophysical properties evaluated and their potential as biomarkers established. The peptidomimetics were used at very low concentrations (10 nM) to follow their internalization in breast cancer cells and had their localization precisely determined.

Morita-Baylis-Hillman reaction: ESI-MS(/MS) investigation with charge tags and ionic liquid effect origin revealed by DFT calculations.

The use of a charge-tagged acrylate derivative bearing an imidazolium tag to study the Morita-Baylis-Hillman reaction via ESI-MS(/MS) monitoring and the effect of such tag (imidazolium cations and ion pairs) over TSs is described. The ionic nature of the substrate was meant to facilitate ESI transfer to the gas phase for direct mass spectrometric analysis. The detection and characterization of charged intermediates has suggested major reaction pathways.

Facts, presumptions, and myths on the solvent-free and catalyst-free Biginelli reaction. What is catalysis for?

The current manuscript describes the role and importance of catalysis and solvent effects for the Biginelli multicomponent reaction. The overwhelming number of new catalysts and conditions recently published for the Biginelli synthesis, including in some manuscripts entitled "catalyst-free" and/or "solvent-free" have incentivized controversies and hot debates regarding the importance of developing new catalysts and reaction conditions to perform this very important multicomponent reaction. These so-called "catalyst-free" reports have generated much confusion in the field, requiring urgent elucidations.

Probing the mechanism of the Ugi four-component reaction with charge-tagged reagents by ESI-MS(/MS).

The mechanism of the Ugi four-component reaction has been investigated by electrospray ionization (tandem) mass spectrometry using charge-tagged reagents (a carboxylic acid or an amine) to favour detection. Key intermediates were transferred directly via ESI(+) from the reaction solution to the gas phase and characterized by MS measurements and MS/MS collision induced dissociation. The Mumm rearrangement (final step) was also investigated by both travelling wave ion mobility mass spectrometry and DFT calculations.

Condensed, solution and gas phase behaviour of mono- and dinuclear 2,6-diacetylpyridine (dap) hydrazone copper complexes probed by X-ray, mass spectrometry and theoretical calculations.

We describe the synthesis of novel mononuclear and dinuclear copper complexes and an investigation of their behaviour in solution using mass spectrometry (ESI-MS and ESI-MS/MS) and in the solid state using X-ray crystallography. The complexes were synthesized from two widely used diacetylpryridine (dap) ligands, i.e.

Novel supramolecular palladium catalyst for the asymmetric reduction of imines in aqueous media.

A novel approach to the asymmetric reduction of dihydro-beta-carboline derivatives to the corresponding tetrahydro-beta-carbolines is described based on the supramolecular lyophilized complex formed from beta-cyclodextrin/imines as an enzyme mimetic and palladium hydride as the reducing agent. The methodology allowed us to develop a short and efficient preparation of (R)-harmicine and (R)-deplancheine alkaloids in high overall yields and ee of 89 and 90%, respectively.