Paediatric emergency front-of-neck airway: issues of ethics, law, and philosophy.

Practitioners can face significant challenges when managing the airways of infants and neonates because of their unique anatomical and physiological features. The requirement for emergency airway management in this age group is rare. Details of emergency airway techniques in paediatric practice guidelines are missing or lack consensus, and it is known that outcomes for affected children can be poor.

Lessons learned from developing a COVID-19 algorithm governance framework in Aotearoa New Zealand.

Aotearoa New Zealand's response to the COVID-19 pandemic has included the use of algorithms that could aid decision making. Te Pokapū Hātepe o Aotearoa, the New Zealand Algorithm Hub, was established to evaluate and host COVID-19 related models and algorithms, and provide a central and secure infrastructure to support the country's pandemic response. A critical aspect of the Hub was the formation of an appropriate governance group to ensure that algorithms being deployed underwent cross-disciplinary scrutiny prior to being made available for quick and safe implementation.

Disagreement over vaccination programmes: deep or merely complex and why does it matter?

This paper argues that significant aspects of the vaccination debate are 'deep' in a sense described by Robert Fogelin and others. Some commentators have suggested that such disagreements warrant rather threatening responses. I argue that appreciating that a disagreement is deep might have positive implications, changing our moral assessment of individuals and their decisions, shedding light on the limits of the obligation to give and respond to arguments in cases of moral disagreement, and providing an incentive to seek alternative ways of going on in the face of intractable moral disagreement.

Paternalism in practice: informing patients about expensive unsubsidised drugs.

Recent research conducted in Australia shows that many oncologists withhold information about expensive unfunded drugs in what the authors of the study suggest is unacceptable medical paternalism. Surprised by the Australian results, we ran a version of the study in New Zealand and received very different results. While the percentages of clinicians who would prescribe the drugs described in the scenarios were very similar (73-99% in New Zealand and 72-94% in Australia depending on the scenario) the percentage who would not discuss expensive unfunded drugs was substantially lower in New Zealand (6.

Parental rights and medical decisions.

Most countries grant parents rebuttable legal rights to make treatment decisions on behalf of their young children, creating a presumption in favor of parental rights. This article identifies and provides a preliminary assessment of a perhaps surprising variety of arguments for the presumption in favor of this parental right. The arguments considered include those flowing from ideas that parents are motivated by their child's best interests; that they have privileged insight into their child's preferences and capacities; that parental support has clinical significance and may be contingent upon respect for the presumption; that parents and families typically bear the burden of treatment decisions; that parents' views often have a religious basis; that it would be improper to override parents' wishes other than in conditions of complete certainty; and that parents have 'natural authority' over their children.

Scoliosis repair in a teenager with Duchenne's muscular dystrophy: who calls the shots?

In this exchange, a clinician (the first author) presents a case scenario for comment by an ethicist (the second author). The case concerns a 15-year-old boy with Duchenne's muscular dystrophy requested palliative surgical correction of a 60 degree thoraco-lumbar scoliosis. The surgical team were initially reluctant to offer surgery given their assessment of the perioperative and postoperative risks (anesthetic review suggested an 80% chance of surviving the surgery and 50% likelihood of returning home), but the operation proceeded.

Mass immunisation programmes: some philosophical issues.

Most countries promote mass immunisation programmes. The varying policy details raise a raft of philosophical issues. I have two broad aims in this paper.