A Career's Work, the l-Arabinose Operon: How It Functions and How We Learned It.

Very few labs have had the good fortune to have been able to focus for more than 50 years on a relatively narrow research topic and to be in a field in which both basic knowledge and the research technology and methods have progressed as rapidly as they have in molecular biology. My research group, first at Brandeis University and then at Johns Hopkins University, has had this opportunity. In this review, therefore, I will describe largely the work from my laboratory that has spanned this period and which was carried out by 40 plus graduate students, several postdoctoral associates, my technician, and me.

Where to From Here?

The biological-biochemical community has been shocked and delighted by the remarkable progress that has recently been made on a problem that has consumed the attention, energy, and resources of many, if not most of the scientists in the field for the past 50 years. The problem has been to predict the tertiary structure of a protein merely from its amino acid sequence. Nature does it easily enough, but it has been an incredibly difficult problem, often considered intractable, for humankind.

Arabinose Alters Both Local and Distal H-D Exchange Rates in the Escherichia coli AraC Transcriptional Regulator.

In the absence of arabinose, the dimeric Escherichia coli regulatory protein of the l-arabinose operon, AraC, represses expression by looping the DNA between distant half-sites. Binding of arabinose to the dimerization domains forces AraC to preferentially bind two adjacent DNA half-sites, which stimulates RNA polymerase transcription of the araBAD catabolism genes. Prior genetic and biochemical studies hypothesized that arabinose allosterically induces a helix-coil transition of a linker between the dimerization and DNA binding domains that switches the AraC conformation to an inducing state [Brown, M.

Helical Behavior of the Interdomain Linker of the Escherichia coli AraC Protein.

In Escherichia coli, the dimeric AraC protein actively represses transcription from the l-arabinose araBAD operon in the absence of arabinose but induces transcription in its presence. Here we provide evidence that, in shifting from the repressing to the inducing state, the behavior of the interdomain linker shifts from that of an α helix to that of a more flexible form. In vivo and in vitro experiments show that AraC with a linker sequence that favors helix formation is shifted toward the repressing state in the absence and presence of arabinose.

A genetic and physical study of the interdomain linker of E. Coli AraC protein--a trans-subunit communication pathway.

Genetic experiments with full length AraC and biophysical experiments with its dimerization domain plus linker suggest that arabinose binding to the dimerization domain changes the properties of the inter-domain linker which connects the dimerization domain to the DNA binding domain via interactions that do not depend on the DNA binding domain. Normal AraC function was found to tolerate considerable linker sequence alteration excepting proline substitutions. The proline substitutions partially activate transcription even in the absence of arabinose and hint that a structural shift between helix and coil may be involved.

Computational and experimental investigation of constitutive behavior in AraC.

Many mutations in the N-terminal arm of AraC result in constitutive behavior in which transcription of the araBAD genes occurs even in the absence of arabinose. To begin to understand the mechanism underlying this class of mutations, we used molecular dynamics with self-guided Langevin dynamics to simulate (1) wild-type (WT) AraC, (2) known constitutive mutants resulting from alterations in the regulatory arm, particularly alanine and glycine substitutions at residue 8 because P8G is constitutive, whereas P8A behaves like wild type, and (3) selected variant AraC proteins containing alterations in the dimerization core. In all of the constitutive arm mutants, but not the WT protein, residues 37-42, which are located in the core of the dimerization domain, became restructured.

Modulation of DNA binding by gene-specific transcription factors.

The transcription of many genes, particularly in prokaryotes, is controlled by transcription factors whose activity can be modulated by controlling their DNA binding affinity. Understanding the molecular mechanisms by which DNA binding affinity is regulated is important, but because forming definitive conclusions usually requires detailed structural information in combination with data from extensive biophysical, biochemical, and sometimes genetic experiments, little is truly understood about this topic. This review describes the biological requirements placed upon DNA binding transcription factors and their consequent properties, particularly the ways that DNA binding affinity can be modulated and methods for its study.

Understanding the basis of a class of paradoxical mutations in AraC through simulations.

Most mutations at position 15 in the N-terminal arm of the regulatory protein AraC leave the protein incapable of responding to arabinose and inducing the proteins required for arabinose catabolism. Mutations at other positions of the arm do not have this behavior. Simple energetic analysis of the interactions between the arm and bound arabinose do not explain the uninducibility of AraC with mutations at position 15.

Heterodimers reveal that two arabinose molecules are required for the normal arabinose response of AraC.

AraC protein, which regulates expression of the l-arabinose operon in Escherichia coli, is a dimer whose DNA binding affinity for pairs of DNA half-sites is controlled by arabinose. Here we have addressed the question of whether the arabinose response of AraC requires the binding of one or two molecules of arabinose. This was accomplished by measuring the DNA dissociation rates of wild-type AraC and heterodimeric AraC constructs in which one subunit is capable of binding arabinose and the other subunit does not bind arabinose.

A new and unexpected domain-domain interaction in the AraC protein.

An interaction between the dimerization domains and DNA binding domains of the dimeric AraC protein has previously been shown to facilitate repression of the Escherichia coli araBAD operon by AraC in the absence of arabinose. A new interaction between the domains of AraC in the presence of arabinose is reported here, the regulatory consequences of which are unknown. Evidence for the interaction is the following: the dissociation rate of arabinose-bound AraC from half-site DNA is considerably faster than that of free DNA binding domain, and the affinity of the dimerization domains for arabinose is increased when half-site DNA is bound.

Active role of the interdomain linker of AraC.

Mutations in the interdomain linker of the gene for the AraC regulatory protein of Escherichia coli that severely interfere with the protein's ability either to repress or to activate transcription have been found. These mutations have relatively small effects on the dimerization domain's ability to bind arabinose or to dimerize the protein or on the DNA-binding domain's affinity for a single DNA half-site. The linker mutations, however, dramatically change the affinity of AraC for binding to two direct-repeat DNA half-sites.

AraC protein, regulation of the l-arabinose operon in Escherichia coli, and the light switch mechanism of AraC action.

This review covers the physiological aspects of regulation of the arabinose operon in Escherichia coli and the physical and regulatory properties of the operon's controlling gene, araC. It also describes the light switch mechanism as an explanation for many of the protein's properties. Although many thousands of homologs of AraC exist and regulate many diverse operons in response to many different inducers or physiological states, homologs that regulate arabinose-catabolizing genes in response to arabinose were identified.

Computational predictions of the mutant behavior of AraC.

An algorithm implemented in Rosetta correctly predicts the folding capabilities of the 17-residue N-terminal arm of the AraC gene regulatory protein when arabinose is bound to the protein and the dramatically different structure of this arm when arabinose is absent. The transcriptional activity of 43 mutant AraC proteins with alterations in the arm sequences was measured in vivo and compared with their predicted folding properties. Seventeen of the mutants possessed regulatory properties that could be directly compared with folding predictions.

A DNA-assisted binding assay for weak protein-protein interactions.

We describe a new method used for quantitating weak interactions between proteins in which the weak interaction is "assisted" by a known DNA-DNA interaction. Oligonucleotides, which are conjugated to proteins of interest, contain short complementary DNA sequences that provide additional binding energy for protein-protein interactions. A stretch of unpaired bases links the protein to the hybridizing DNA sequence to allow formation of both protein-protein and DNA-DNA interactions with minimal structural interference.

Solution structure of the DNA binding domain of AraC protein.

We report the solution structure of the DNA binding domain of the Escherichia coli regulatory protein AraC determined in the absence of DNA. The 20 lowest energy structures, determined on the basis of 1507 unambiguous nuclear Overhauser restraints and 180 angle restraints, are well resolved with a pair wise backbone root mean square deviation of 0.7 A.

Opposite allosteric mechanisms in TetR and CAP.

Regulation of the DNA binding affinity of an oligomeric protein can be considered to consist of an intrinsic component, in which the affinity of an individual DNA-binding domain is modulated in response to effector binding, and an extrinsic component, in which the relative position of the protein's two DNA-binding domains are altered so that they can or cannot contact both half-site operators simultaneously. We demonstrated directly that the TetR repressor utilizes an extrinsic mechanism and CAP, the catabolite activator protein, utilizes an intrinsic mechanism.

Constitutive mutations in the Escherichia coli AraC protein.

The Escherichia coli AraC protein represses and induces the araBAD operon in response to the absence or presence of l-arabinose. Constitutive mutations in the AraC gene no longer require the presence of l-arabinose to convert AraC from its repressing to its inducing state. Such mutations were isolated directly by virtue of their constitutivity or by their resistance to the nonmetabolizable arabinose analog, d-fucose.

Functional modes of the regulatory arm of AraC.

One of the two crystal structures of the arm-dimerization domain determined in the absence of arbinose fails to show the arm, whereas the other structure does show it. The two structures lead to different pictures for the regulatory behavior of the arms. Trypsin digestion, fluorescence anisotropy, and NMR experiments presented here were designed to resolve the issue and show that in arm-dimerization domain, the arms are structured, although differently, in the presence and absence of arabinose.

The salt dependence of the interferon regulatory factor 1 DNA binding domain binding to DNA reveals ions are localized around protein and DNA.

The equilibrium dissociation constant of the DNA binding domain of interferon regulatory factor 1 (IRF1 DBD) for its DNA binding site depends strongly on salt concentration and salt type. These dependencies are consistent with IRF1 DBD binding to DNA, resulting in the release of cations from the DNA and both release of anions from the protein and uptake of a cation by the protein. We demonstrated this by utilizing the fact that the release of fluoride from protein upon complex formation does not contribute to the salt concentration dependence of binding and by studying mutants in which charged residues in IRF1 DBD that form salt bridges with DNA phosphates are changed to alanine.

DNA tape measurements of AraC.

A new method for measuring distances between points in the AraC-DNA complex was developed and applied. It utilizes variable lengths of single-stranded DNA that connect double-stranded regions containing the two half-site binding sequences of AraC. These distances plus the protein interdomain linker distances are compatible with two classes of structure for the dimeric AraC gene regulatory protein.

Structure and properties of a truely apo form of AraC dimerization domain.

The arabinose-binding pockets of wild type AraC dimerization domains crystallized in the absence of arabinose are occupied with the side chains of Y31 from neighboring domains. This interaction leads to aggregation at high solution concentrations and prevents determination of the structure of truely apo AraC. In this work we found that the aggregation does not significantly occur at physiological concentrations of AraC.

Specific interactions by the N-terminal arm inhibit self-association of the AraC dimerization domain.

Deletion of the regulatory N-terminal arms of the AraC protein from its dimerization domain fragments increases the susceptibility of the dimerization domain to form a series of higher order polymers by indefinite self-association. We investigated how the normal presence of the arm inhibits this self-association. One possibility is that arms can act as an entropic bristles to interfere with the approach of other macromolecules, thereby decreasing collision frequencies.

Arm-domain interactions can provide high binding cooperativity.

Peptidyl arms extending from one protein domain to another protein domain mediate many important interactions in biology. A well-studied example of this type of protein-protein interaction occurs between the yeast homeodomain proteins, MAT alpha2 and MAT a1, which form a high-affinity heterodimer on DNA. The carboxyl-terminal arm extending from MAT alpha2 to MAT a1 has been proposed to produce an allosteric conformational change in the a1 protein that generates a very large increase in the DNA binding affinity of a1.

A portable allosteric mechanism.

The allosteric mechanism by which the gene expression regulatory protein AraC regulates its DNA-binding activity is shown to be portable by grafting it to beta-galactosidase, generating an arabinose-regulated beta-galactosidase. A portion of the alpha-peptide sequence that complements the activity of alpha-acceptor beta-galactosidase was inserted into a nonessential region of the regulatory peptidyl arm of AraC protein. Arabinose, which regulates the position of the arm in AraC protein now regulates the availability of the alpha-peptide to alpha-acceptor beta-galactosidase, thereby modulating its activity in response to arabinose.