Binder ratio in the two-dimensional q-state clock model.

We study phase transition properties of the two-dimensional q-state clock model by an extensive Monte Carlo simulation. By analyzing the Binder ratio and its temperature derivative, we confirm that the two-dimensional q-state clock model exhibits two distinct Kosterlitz-Thouless phase transitions for q=5,6 but it has one second-order phase transition for q=4. The critical temperatures are estimated quite accurately from the crossing behavior of the Binder ratio (for q<5) and from negative divergent dips of the derivative of the Binder ratio (for q≥5) around these critical points.